Best Fly Fishing Gifts (2020)

I hope everyone had a good Thanksgiving. I know that this year is an oddity in many ways, one requiring change and adaptation.

One personal area of change for me has been this: I’m just not buying that much new fishing gear. Part of it could be that I’m up to seven trout fly rods and am feeling that the quiver is full. The other part is that I’m really happy with 2019’s gift ideas, noted below, all of which I use regularly and heartily endorse. Two new additions: a new set of Orvis waders and a lifetime Trout Unlimited membership.

As mentioned previously, our blog donates 100% of our profits (in past years, to Project Healing Waters and Casting for Recovery). Part of our revenue comes from Amazon affiliate links, such as those highlighted below. Clicking the links and buying the products will support this blog and two awesome charities. Thanks for thinking of us!

Here is the list in ascending price order, from stocking stuffers to stand-alone gifts:


Rainbow Scud Dubbing (light shade) (link)
$7. I normally scoff at the notion of magical material. I no longer do, now that I’ve discovered rainbow scud dubbing. I’ve had many days when fish are not taking until I put on a pattern that uses this material. Sometimes, just a touch of this stuff is more than enough. For some reason, it works really well with rainbows. I make flies with this dubbing from a size 10 down to 20.


CDC Feathers (link)
$7. These are unbeatable for small emerger patterns or for nymphs at slow-ish water. Their life-like movement is a strong strike trigger. On some days when pressured trout are gun-shy, a pattern that incorporates CDC has saved my outing.


Frog’s Fanny (link)
$10. A great floatant, and I think is the best one out there. It’s particularly good for CDC flies, as regular floatant mats down the fibers.

This is a must-have, IMO, if you fish the Swift, Farmington and the Upper Connecticut’s “Trophy Stretch.” CDC dries work very well when targeting educated fish at such tailwaters.



Magnetic Fly Box (link)
$10. If you fish midges, you know how easy it is to lose them on a windy or cold day, and how annoying it is to take them in and out of foam slots. What’s saved me is having a thin fly box that has magnetized panels. I like one with many compartments, and this is where I store flies from sizes 20 to 30.




Small Hook Sharpener (link)
$12 to $16. Makes a huge difference on hook-up rates. Noted angler George Daniel notes that it is his most-often used accessory on the river. I agree. You’d be surprised how nymph hooks can get very dull very quickly. I sharpen my hooks often. It’s cheap insurance.




Tom Fuller’s Trout Streams of Southern New England (link)
$18. One of the best fly fishing books I’ve read. Detailed write ups on flies, access points and parking areas for countless waters in CT, MA and RI.

It is like having a guide with you at the house at all times. It’s how I started fishing the Farmington, Millers, Nissitissit, Swift, Squannacook, etc. I didn’t need a guide as a rookie. I still refer to it regularly as I search for new waters.



Ed Engle’s Tying Small Flies (link)
$25. If you fish the Upper Connecticut Trophy Stretch, Deerfield, Farmington or Swift, this book is a must-have, IMO. Engle focuses on fishing tailwaters in Colorado. Many of those lessons learned apply to us out east. And, they’ve worked for me in spades.

His fly-tying instructions are detailed and include many photos. He has some imaginative patterns, and they just plain work. A great book.



Jason Randall’s Feeding Time (link)
$25. Reading this book a few years ago really changed how I fly fished. Randall gives a very clear view as to what drives trout behavior, namely, two instincts: resting and feeding.

You’ll see why trout are incredible “calorie capitalists.” You’ll understand better why trout at certain times want only small flies and why, at other times, they’ll take something large.




Rio Leader Wallet (link)
$25. This is always in my chest pack, as it is small and light and lets me hold multiple leaders (different sizes, but different styles, too, for dries, Euro-nymphing, streamers and regular indicator nymphing), Euro sighters and spare materials.

I like being organized on the water because it lets me find things fast so that I can maximize my time fishing vs. sorting and fiddling.


Frabill Net 3672 (link)
$28. This is a rubber net that is extremely durable. The rubber is easier on a fish’s gills, and nymphs don’t easily get tangled in the net. It’s very light, too. My old rubber net came with a wood handle; it looked sharp. This net is much lighter.

The 3672 is 13″ x 18″ and is big enough to hold larger fish. I like an ample net. After I catch a big one, I keep the fish in the net and water. I wedge the net among some rocks and let the trout recover at its own pace.


George Daniel’s Dynamic Nymphing (link)
$32. This book really is the source, whether you tightline or throw indicators.

As a two-time national champion, George has a world’s worth of knowledge; but, he also has the ability to share his insights in a very understandable manner. From rigging to trade-offs to favorite gear to flies, this must-have book is really a reference manual, given the plethora of information it offers.



Tiemco 2488 Hook, size 20 (link)
$30 for 100. This is my favorite hook. The thin wire means that it easily sets with just a calm flick of the wrist. It has a 3x gape for tremendous hook-and-hold power, which is critical for tiny hooks. I have them in sizes 16 to 26. They are my go-to choice for dropper flies, from soft hackles to emergers to midge larvae/pupae.



Stonfo Elite Rotodubbing Twister (link)
$44. This ingenious tool makes for a very handy way to make dubbed bodies for nymphs and streamers. It helps me save a ton of time.


Fly Tying Light and Magnifier (link)
$65. People often ask me how I can make flies down to size 30. Here’s the answer! The quality of my fly tying went up dramatically after I started using a light and magnification lens.

I think investing in good lighting and magnification is the one item that has dramatically increased the quality of my flies. If you can’t see ’em, you can’t make ’em.



Montana Mongoose Vise (link)
$181. You won’t need to buy multiple vise tips. This one handles big streamer hooks and small hooks down to size 30. Full rotary, feather-size gauge, materials clip and bobbin holder, too. And, it comes with a light-weight clamp and travel case for trips.




Orvis PRO Waders (link)
$498. I love these. I’ve had waders from Simms, LL Bean and other Orvis ones, and these are my favorite. They’re very durable, and feature removable knee pads, critical for low-water conditions. The waders are breathable and feature a Kangaroo-style handwarmer pocket for cold days, a flip-out interior pocket, and a removable waterproof pocket. Comes with attached gravel guards. I’ve been fishing all year with these and really like them. A cut above the pack, IMO.



Thomas and Thomas Contact 11’3″ #3 (link)
$795. As I wrote previously (here), if I could pick only one fly rod, this would be it.

I like the length for longer casting and the ability to guide nymphs down multiple current seams without moving your feet. And, the rod is very accurate. Target a soft seam from afar, and the rod does a great job.

This fly rod can do everything very well, from dries to indicator nymphing to all types of Euro techniques. It feels amazingly light, but, has a strong back end that lets you quickly bring in a fish. This is an All-Star stick and could be a gift to which multiple family members and friends contribute. And, the company is local, in Greenfield, MA.

Last, my biggest present to myself this year has been a lifetime membership to Trout Unlimited. The more I’ve learned about the organization, the more impressed I’ve been. I eschewed the fly rod gift so that TU can use the entire dollar amount to fight for conservation. It’s a great group filled with great folks. In fact, I gave my gift in honor of blog friend Gary Metras and TU Director of Volunteer Operations Jeff Yates.

Happy Holidays to you and yours!


Discover more from

Subscribe to get the latest posts to your email.

7 thoughts on “Best Fly Fishing Gifts (2020)

    1. Great point, Jack. Damon and I had a float penciled in with him in the spring. We will reschedule once we all get the all-clear….

      1. How can I get in touch with him? I don’t have a number for him. Was under the impression he wasn’t guiding any longer. If you prefer you can send it to my email

  1. Wow, before reading this article, I hadn’t realized how many of your 2019 gift ideas made it to my Santa list. Some of your new ones will too. When a proficient and trusted local fisherman gives advice on products, you can’t beat that!

    I bought my first pair of Orvis waders in September. They weren’t the Pro waders, but were the Clearwater middle-of-the line waders. I love the fit and the no-nonsense amenities.

    Thanks for the great suggestions.

    1. Bill, you’re very kind. I’ve received a lot of great advice over the years from so many great anglers. So, the list is really their work, not mine.

      Hope you had a good T-giving!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *