The Wild One

Every so often, our family’s crazy schedule is such that everyone else is out of town. For me, that means guilt-free fly fishing.

Many of you have children, and you know what I mean.

So, I decided to take some vacation time and do an overnight trip at the Farmington. My spring-break holiday. For the first time in a long while, I was skunked during my last trip there. So, I wanted to return.

After a run to Logan airport to drop off family, I arrived at the river at 9 am, much later than my usual start time. The water was 38 °F, and I decided to start by throwing the ol’ indicator at new water for me up along Hogback Road. To boot, it was very cold and windy.

Amazingly, I caught two rainbows in quick succession. One looked newly-stocked, but the other one was quite dark. A third fish broke me off on some underwater structure.

I love the pulsing electricity that happens when there is a fish at the end of the line and the fly rod is bent.

Happy, and seeking more seasoned fish, I reeled up. Stockies are great and all, but I wanted a different kind of fish. So, I drove to other spots, both familiar and new. The Farmington is massive, and I enjoy trying multiple areas. Unfortunately, none of them had fish for me!

The hours passed.

At one point, as I munched on a PB&J, I thought about what, if anything, I needed to do differently. I decided to hit an area which I knew had fish. I figured the hide-and-seek game was one I was starting to lose.

So, I drove to one of my favorite stretches, which is in the TMA. Some stoneflies and midges were popping, and I thought that “floating the sighter” at some bubbly and shallow water might work.

It is a very fun way to fish. Rather than using an indicator, you grease the sighter and use light nymphs. My Euronymphing leader has a stiff butt end and casts well. When greased, the sighter’s “whiskers” are easy to spot in low-light conditions.

When the sighter jerks forward, you raise the rod tip. The technique works best if you are directly below the target zone so that the leader floats on one current seam. The alternative is to mend the line downstream.

Thankfully, it worked. Two more rainbows showed up. This area had not been stocked, and it made me wonder if I was getting lucky with holdovers.

At this point, the wind really started to gust. But, I worked some more areas.

Then it happened. The fish for which I had been waiting all day: The Wild One.

It was a brown with intact fins and that measured 15″. Not a giant, but, it was thick and fought well. It really is tough to beat wild fish. They’re savvy and hard fighters.

With that, it was time to reel up, as I was very, very cold. One hot shower later at Legends, I felt revived and grateful.

It was great to chat with the owner, Sal Tartaglione, who recently landed a 20″+ fish. I also spoke with Louis, who works at UpCountry. It was fun to speak with others who also are passionate about fly fishing.

A great day.


The next morning, temperatures had fallen and were continuing to go down by the hour. The wind was blowing at 20 mph, and the gusts were even stronger.

I decided to fish anyway. Heck, I was already there, and I figured it would be a fun challenge. I decided to avoid the newly-stocked areas and gun for more wild fish.

The wind was already insane when I got to the river. I worked an area as the only angler for a few hours (only one other person showed up all morning). It was hard to cast, as the wind created tangles and drag.

So, after thinking about it, I decided to grease up again the sighter. With the rod tip low, I figure I could minimize the amount of line exposed to the wind’s vagaries.

Thankfully, it worked. Within a few casts, the sighter jumped forward. Fish on.

It took a little bit of doing to tame the fish. When I slid it into the net, I was surprised that it wasn’t bigger, given how hard it pulled.

The brown was probably 12″ or so, and it looked clean. The picture doesn’t do justice to how vibrant it looked.

I stuck around until noon, but that was my only take of the morning. That’s more than fine. I saw another wild trout, and that’s enough for me.


Discover more from

Subscribe to get the latest posts to your email.

12 thoughts on “The Wild One

  1. I’m using your sight indicator system and am pleased with the way it feels on a 11′ 3 wt hydrogen. Question is how many sighter knots are on your bicolor section ( I think I have 5) and do you leave the whiskers on all or some of them? Do you use that system when you switch to an indicator? Thanks!

  2. Great post, thanks! Every so often you describe a characteristic or two of a stocked or wild trout and it had me curious if you have ever done a blog post on how to recognize the difference between the two. I would love to be able to identify the difference when on the water, especially with the stocking season close to being in full swing. Thanks again for the great content!

    1. Some of the info will be specific to the Farmington. Survivor Strain browns usually have an elastomer behind an eye (schedule here):

      And, a clipped adipose fin.

      Wild fish do not. The wild ones also have very large and smooth-edged pectoral fins. The dorsal fin is also large, translucent at the base, and is not bent over.

      When fish spend time in a hatchery tank, their fins get worn down and/or ragged.

  3. This is a very interesting technique which I have never tried. Even more impressive with the wind! Whats the typical fly setup (pattern/weight) you use with it and what type of water (depth/flow) are you targeting? What length of drift do you get? Why choose it over dry dropper?

    1. Pattern and weight really depend on bugs in the water, the casting distance and the wind. I want enough weight but not too much, as I am trying to suspend the nymphs higher up in the water column. OK for the flies to sink, but I want them to slowly glide down.

      I like water that is hip-length or lower and is bubbly or has a broken surface. Speed is a guess. Not slow or fast, something in between. But, I’ve used this technique successfully at some of the very slow and technical areas of the Swift.

      Probably a 5’ drift.

      For certain conditions, this method is better than a dry-dropper, as I have more flies submerged. The mono is very stealthy, too, making very little surface commotion. I also like the nymphs to slowly sink which I cannot do with a fixed length between a dry and a dropper. Easier to adjust weight, too.

      1. So you would use this method if you saw surface activity or suspected a hatch was going on vs the more traditional tightline where closer to the bottom would be your target?

        1. If I see splashes, I will switch to dries.

          If I don’t see splashes, but see some shallow and bubbly water where I think fish may be, I will float the sighter if I have the casting angle and in lieu of a strike indicator.

          This method is much more sensitive than a floating indicator; there is no hinge (which indicators cause), and, you can maintain contact with the nymphs. It takes practice, though, to eliminate slack while not pulling the flies. The best way is to have just part of your sighter on the water while you move or lift the rod tip to remove slack from the system.

          Water temps have to be right. If it is too cold, the fish will be deep and hunkered down. When I saw many bugs popping, I had a feeling that some fish had moved up to feed.

          The Euro method is very versatile. It lets you work many levels of the water column. You just adjust the weight of the setup by swapping flies. It is why I have many versions of the same fly but vary the size of, and the material for, the bead. Glass beads can be magical, for example.

  4. Great report Jo! I’m planning to get out in the next day or so. The string of nor’easters put a damper in my plans……..

  5. Hat’s off to you for fishing in that gale. I took the weekend off and tied flies.
    You make a good point about tying lighter, not necessarily smaller versions of your favorite patterns.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *